STICK A FORK IN IT

Thursday, October 27th, 2011 | Uncategorized

The Anglican Covenant is done:

Sydney has rejected the Anglican Covenant. The 11 October vote by the 49th meeting of the Diocese of Sydney Synod likely spells the death knell for Dr Rowan Williams’ plan for a global agreement to set the parameters of doctrine and discipline for the Anglican Communion.

Support for the Covenant peaked in the run-up to the 2009 meeting of the Anglican Consultative Council in Kingston, however, Dr Williams’ untimely intervention into the Covenant debate and changes made to the document have alienated both left and right.

Liberal dioceses in New Zealand, Australia and the US have rejected the plan as un-Anglican, while the Global South Primates last year stated that “while we acknowledge that the efforts to heal our brokenness through the introduction of an Anglican Covenant were well intentioned, we have come to the conclusion the current text is fatally flawed and so support for this initiative is no longer appropriate.”

Good riddance.  As George Conger correctly states, no one likes this thing.  Liberals refuse to agree to anything that might limit their theological innovations while conservatives have known for a long time that the Covenant, as written, has no teeth and cannot rein in the Canadians and the Americans.

What now?  I suppose Rowan Williams could kick the can down the road once more and take another run at it.  Of course, any new covenant, however many years it takes to create one, will be even more worthless than the current one is.

If Dr. Williams was as intelligent as people think he is, he would forget about Anglican covenants altogether, drop the idea of who is “officially” Anglican and who isn’t and let the Anglican world revert to its pre-1868 condition.  But I don’t think Dr. Williams is as intelligent as people think he is.

9 Comments to STICK A FORK IN IT

Michael D
October 27, 2011

It was just a delaying tactic anyway, and not one of his better ones.

Katherine
October 27, 2011

It wasn’t a bad idea at the beginning, if it had been taken as intended. But it wasn’t taken as intended. Canterbury and New York twisted and turned it until it was entirely useless, insulting much of the Global South in the process.

Jim the Puritan
October 27, 2011

There really is no “Anglican Communion” any longer, or if there is, the Archbishop of Canterbury is no longer part of it.

Allen Lewis
October 28, 2011

Agree with all the prior posts. Dr. Rowan Williams will go down in history as the man who “killed” the Anglican Communion. Of course, he had a lot of help from his own feckless priests and bishops.

Dale Matson
October 28, 2011

Perhaps the most distressing thing to me about Rowan Williams was that he had a stealth liberal agenda from the beginning. Conservatives kept expecting and waiting for a firm line in the sand that never came. This bought the liberals in the U.S., Canada and the UK time to advance their liberal agenda unchecked and undisciplined. Like a chess player, he kept asserting that his primary goal was to keep the Anglican Communion together (unity). This was a knight he placed in front of a bishop to conceal the bishop’s trajectory. When the knight was moved a second time, it uncovered the bishop which threatened the queen (Anglican Communion). The bishop was TEC. It was never about unity. It was about advancing an agenda.

Michael D
October 28, 2011

Not sure I follow the details of that chess metaphor, Dale, but I think the conservatives were rooked.

Creedal Episcopalian
October 28, 2011

Dr. Rowan Williams did not kill the Anglican Communion. The powers manipulating TEC did. They twisted his arm with Trinity Wall Street money.

The covenant as originally written would have isolated The revisionist western Anglicans, and would have been acceptable to the majority of the communion. It had to be torpedoed so it was not acceptable to anybody, and, with Williams’s manipulations, it was. But I think he was forced to do it.

Dale Matson
October 28, 2011

Creedal Episcopalian,
Rowan Williams may not have been the matador but was at least the picador.

Clown Celebrant
October 28, 2011

Rowan Williams has a patina of intelligence, let’s be clear about that. But, practical intelligence? No. Anyway, everyone but the ACI knew the so-called covenant-that-would-never-be-a-covenant-because-if-the-Newyorkopalian-Church-adopted-it-they-would-immediately-violate-it was a stupid waste of time.

Support The MCJ

Search

Links

Meta