VESTMENTS CONTROVERSY

Friday, January 30th, 2009 | Uncategorized

The MCJ’s Northeast bureau chief sends along this reason why some of us don’t mind calling ourselves Puritans:

Related story here.

16 Comments to VESTMENTS CONTROVERSY

Steve L.-
January 30, 2009

I thought it was a little early for Halloween

Christopher Hathaway
January 30, 2009

Soooooooooo….
She thinks that her religious vestments should reflect her PERSONALITY????!, and of course the glory of God’s creation.

How to respond that doesn’t involve heavy artillery.
Um….perhaps the purpose of the vestments of ministers of God is to reflect HIS(!!!!) glory.

Peter C.
January 30, 2009

To quote one of my favorite sayings: “There are few problems in this world that cannot be solved with a suitable application of high explosives.”

Allen Lewis
January 30, 2009

My wife custom makes liturgical garb (copes, chasubles, stoles) and altar parements (frontals, pulpit & lectern hangings, banners, etc.) at reasonable prices to supply start-up congregations, small parishes, and congregations with limited funds. [Note: click on the link to Shelter In the Storm and then from there, click on Church Mouse Designs for some samples.] Her work ranges from traditional to somewhat modern, but it does not go into the realm of the bizarre.

We are not talking about fashion here, folks. We are talking about liturgical garb which serves not only to remind the congregation of the season of the church year and its theme, but also to focus on God and serve as an intimation of the glory which we will experience in His Kingdom.

I find this prancing about like Super Models extremely offensive and believe it dishonors the function of liturgical vestments. They are not there to make a statement, they are there to celebrate the glory of the Most High God.

Bill2
January 30, 2009

Where were the oven mitts?

FW Ken
January 30, 2009

Did that young man say he wanted to re-use Christian symbols for “today’s doctrines”? I listened twice and couldn’t hear it.

And surely he didn’t say that.

As to the Puritan thing Chris, growing up Baptist I remember sartorial elegance not as colorful, but certainly as prideful.

Janjan
January 31, 2009

Allen,
your wife’s designs are very dignified. I have actually done some liturgical embroidery, and as an artist I really don’t have an objection to beautifying worship. In fact in the Jewish tradition there is a “Hidur Mitzvah”. “Beautifying the commandment”, which has the idea of honoring God with beauty in the worship.

It is when you start getting into the realm of distraction, and the bizarre that it falls apart. The thing that gets me about this “fashion show” is how self centered it all is. I also thought the idea that female clergy have brought in the “style” element, highly amusing.

Here in Boston, at the Church of the Advent (Anglo-Catholic), the celebrant usually wears a very grand, gold embroidered cope (? cape?). It’s antique, and very very grand. The idea is that the celebrant is handling sacred materials, the actual Body of Christ, so therefore this calls for something regal. It’s certainly not about the priest.

Janjan
January 31, 2009

FW Ken, he said “for today’s culture”.

midwestnorwegian
January 31, 2009

You have got to be depraved to even find this crap! ;-)

Thanks for the Saturday chuckle.

Robb
January 31, 2009

“A pretty girl is like a melody”……….

Roz
January 31, 2009

No matter how appropriate or inappropriate the actual vestments, seeing priests doubling as runway models just odds me out.

Daniel Muller
January 31, 2009

seeing runway models doubling as priests just odds me out.

Fixed.

The Little Myrmidon
January 31, 2009

So, what happened to “Ad Majorem Dei Gloriam“? In addition to the priest handling the Body of Christ, the vestments are also supposed to serve as a sort of uniform in the sense that we don’t focus on the priest as an individual, but rather on his function during the eucharist.

As for this “fashion show”…eeuuuww!

FW Ken
January 31, 2009

Thanks, JanJan.

And yes, the vestments on parade made me queasy, too.

Ed the Roman
January 31, 2009

It is a cope.

Geoffrey Peckham
January 31, 2009

Vestments as political statements. Right.

Support The MCJ

Search

Links

Meta