CAMLANN
Wednesday, March 10th, 2010 | Uncategorized
South Carolina isn’t stupid. South Carolina knows. But South Carolina won’t flinch:
RESOLVED, That this 219th Convention of the Diocese of South Carolina affirms its legal and ecclesiastical authority as a sovereign diocese within the Episcopal Church, and be it further
RESOLVED, That this Convention declares the Presiding Bishop has no authority to retain attorneys in this Diocese that present themselves as the legal counsel for the Episcopal Church in South Carolina, and be it finally
RESOLVED, That the Diocese of South Carolina demands that the Presiding Bishop drop the retainer of all such legal counsel in South Carolina as has been obtained contrary to the express will of this Diocese, which is The Episcopal Church within its borders.
The Ecclesiastical Authority of the Diocese is the Bishop. If there is no Bishop, the Standing Committee is the Ecclesiastical Authority. The Ecclesiastical Authority of the Diocese, with the advice and counsel of the Chancellor, is the sole and final authority with respect to any dispute concerning the interpretation of the Constitution and Canons of this Diocese and its interpretations shall be final and binding in all respects.
Resolved, that the following Section be added to Canon XXX.
Section 6. “It is within the power of the Ecclesiastical Authority of this Diocese to provide a generous pastoral response to parishes in conflict with the Diocese or Province, as the Ecclesiastical Authority judges necessary, to preserve the unity and integrity of the Diocese.”
Explanation:
1. The actions of the Presiding Bishop’s office, now publicly acknowledged, have demonstrated a clear willingness and intent both to legally pursue congregations we consider parishes in good standing, and attempt to utilize diocesan resources to do so.
2. We’ve experienced now as a diocese, in the All Saints, Pawleys Island litigation, the destructive force of such litigation; how it has created animosities and divisions that are not easily healed. It has failed as a positive cohesive force for maintaining the unity of the church and has in fact had precisely the opposite effect. Christians are suing Christians (I Cor. 6:1-8); the reputation of the church is marred, and vital resources are diverted from essential Kingdom work. None of this is honoring to our Savior.
3. It has been the implicit understanding of this Diocese that the Bishop inherently has the authority to deal with such situations. The current practice of the Bishop to deal pastorally with parishes struggling with their relationship with the Diocese or Province must be given explicit canonical force. The discretion exercised by the bishop is the only way to successfully navigate the current challenges before us.
I’ve made it clear again and again how I feel about remaining connected to the Episcopalians. The battle is over and the left has won so continuing to defend little bridges is not brave but spiritually suicidal.
That said, I can’t help but admire South Carolina’s stance. I don’t know what the legal situation in that state is; the Curmudgeon is probably the go-to guy for any questions you might have in that area.
The Gamecocks might be able to hold 815 off for a while, maybe even a long while. But they won’t hold them off forever. After all, Mrs. Schori can muddy the waters whenever the mood strikes her.
We’ve all seen the pattern. The Presiding Bishop will discover that Mark Lawrence has “abandoned communion,” depose him and appoint another one of her sock puppets in his place. The Standing Committee will go next replaced by still more of her tools.
After that, Mrs. Schori will stand back and let the courts decide who the “real” Diocese of South Carolina is and, particularly important in TEO’s case, who gets to spend Diocesan money, thus effectively hamstringing any effective Anglican witness in South Carolina for years to come.
It will be painful to contemplate the possibility that such magnificent Anglican landmarks as St. Michael’s of Charleston, which I visited during my one and only trip to that most enchanting of American cities, or St. Philip’s, which I didn’t get to, might fall, if only temporarily, under the control of that loathsome cult. But we Anglican conservatives brought this on ourselves.
And we need to keep reminding ourselves that here we have no continuing city but we seek one to come.
30 Comments to CAMLANN
For an historical parallel, review the invasion of Poland by Germany 1939. The part of the Soviets is played by the ABC.
March 10, 2010
I love it that they used the same phrase “generous pastoral response”
that was so often used a couple of years back in regard to same sex union.
March 10, 2010
“The battle is over and the left has won so continuing to defend little bridges is not brave but spiritually suicidal.”
Like defending imaginary little bridges in Sodom and Gomorrah.
“That said, I can’t help but admire South Carolina’s stance.”
I don’t admire DioSC or +Lawrence. I admire +Schofield and DioSJ. Against WO. Bolted out of TEc. And got lambasted by Institutionalist-Enabler Ephraim Radner in the New York Times.
And fwiw, I admire rector Steve Wood. Anyone know what the latest news is on Rector Steve Wood and his church? He needs to protect his flock and get them out of both TEc AND the DioSC.
Goodbye PBess, goodbye Bishop Lawrence.
March 10, 2010
TU&D,
Thanks for the affirmation of our Bishop JDS and Diocese. I met with him on Monday and his health is returning following heart surgery. He is full of vim and vinegar and new ideas. His enthusiasm is contagious.
He is a visionary.
My understanding of SC law is that if 815 makes any serious efforts to interfere, they will get their butts handed to them.
March 10, 2010
Matthew,
“…they will get their butts handed to them.” What other part is there?
March 10, 2010
Dale,
This far into the farce and you need to ask?
March 10, 2010
Well, the reason for the “appeal”, was that our Supreme Court ruled that the Denis Canon had no standing in this state. And the latest kerfluffle with someone here trying to “represent” TEC tried to get confidential information from our Chancellor under the guise of friendship. He was a former Diocesan Chancellor for 10 years and claimed to “represent TEC”.
If indeed this guy did represent TEC, then +Lawrence is telling TEC where to go.. LOL (in polite terms).
The churches wishing to depart are sticking with him for now. St. Andrews Mt. Pleasant will BE at the upcoming convention, and Steve+ says the resolutions NEED to pass..
Hope this helps.
Grandmother in SC
March 10, 2010
Where is that applause button???
March 10, 2010
And when Mark Lawrence retires? Yeah, he’s young, he’s new. He’s mortal.
Who’s going to succeed him? What will the HOB look like in twenty years?
There will never be another Episcopal bishop who doesn’t like teh geh.
March 10, 2010
“the Loathsome Cult”
)
March 10, 2010
“TU&D,
Thanks for the affirmation of our Bishop JDS and Diocese. I met with him on Monday and his health is returning following heart surgery. He is full of vim and vinegar and new ideas. His enthusiasm is contagious.
He is a visionary.”
He had a vision of fulfilling the Great Commission which would be so much better and spiritually healthier when his flock was safely outside of TEc.
+Lawrence doesn’t.
March 10, 2010
the PBess should have done a little research on South Carolinians before poking a stick into Bishop Lawrence’s cage…http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edmund_Ruffin
March 10, 2010
And when Mark Lawrence retires?
TEC and its lawyers are worried that, before Lawrence retires, he will watch helplessly as all his precious sheep escape to join a Christian Province, through a great big legal loophole created by the SC Supreme Court.
I’m sure
the good bishop has not thought of that.
Go little sheep! Go!
March 10, 2010
Good to hear that Bishop Schofield’s health is improving. May God continue to bless him.
If Bishop Lawrence is able to beat back 815 in court, and he’s taking a positive step towards doing that, then the future for SC may or may not be TEC. If their power over him is only ecclesiastical, they have no power over him.
March 10, 2010
Sasha you have odd fantasies, perhaps better left off this site.
March 10, 2010
Chris,
I am loathe to correct a fellow blogger but I simply must point out this obvious typo:
The Standing Committee will go next replaced by still more of hertoolsfools.
March 10, 2010
Probably you’re right – if that’s why my comment has been deleted (as can be seen), I don’t mind. Hopefully Google or somebody else won’t have had time to take a snapshot thereof…
It’s simply my wish that all that evil those Commies in TEO are doing would somehow or other be stopped – and no, I’ve no intention or desire to get involved in any immoral activity.
Nevertheless, it could be seriously the case that Mark Lawrence IS secretly out to have his parishes escape TEO’s clutches, which would truly be wonderful!
March 10, 2010
Michael D: “Go little sheep! Go!”
Yes. Even if +Lawrence doesn’t.
March 10, 2010
The shepherd, of course, must be the last to leave. Like Gandalf against the Balrog, saying “fly, you fools!”
March 10, 2010
The Curmudgeon has written about the TEO’s “take over” procedure at http://accurmudgeon.blogspot.com/2009/02/machiavelli-ritornato.html
.
March 10, 2010
I should say litigation strategy–is there a difference?
March 11, 2010
Michael D: “The shepherd, of course, must be the last to leave.”
Has the shepherd informed the sheep that they need to leave TEc?
March 11, 2010
TUAD: I doubt it – one must be very cautious when guarding sheep from wolves, not to give the wolves an advantage.
Why do you ask? Are you a wolf?
March 11, 2010
Michael D,
Are you a wolf-enabler?
Camlann? This South Carolinian is thinking Fort Sumter.
+Lawrence is still operating, apparently, on the belief that there is a reasonable way out for the Diocese of SC. I am afraid that he – and others in the Diocese, who did not want to face the obvious – are in for a rude awakening. The SC Supreme Court ruling in the All Saint’s Waccamaw case will be helpful, but will it be enough?
In my opinion, the Diocese will die an agonizing death because there is no united leadership which has a vision other than of “dithering” and hoping for the best.
Right now, the Diocese’s choices are very limited. I do pray for them and wish them well. It will be a sad thing to see the church in which I grew up destroyed. But I am afraid that is what is going to happen. The people who really believe in the principles of Anglicanism have left long ago. The ones which are left….
I would not go so far as my friend TU..AD, but I sense that there is a lack of real passion for the Anglican Way in most of the parishes within the diocese. Even St. Andrew’s (led by Steve Woods+) is more of an evangelical, praise ‘n’ worship entity than it is Anglican. There still is the issue of WO in the diocese. So I am not too hopeful for the future of the Anglicans in the Diocese of SC.
We can only hope and pray.
Makes me glad I left for the ACC when I did.
March 11, 2010
Allen Lewis: “In my opinion, the Diocese will die an agonizing death because there is no united leadership which has a vision other than of “dithering” and hoping for the best.”
I will go as far as my friend Allen Lewis and fully agree with him.
An undershepherd who allows his flock to “die an agonizing death” is not a good undershepherd.
March 12, 2010
Regardless of what happens in the Diocese, and I am praying daily for the Diocese, the good Bishop Lawrence, and for the larger church to come to its senses, it does seem that the TEO is after a lot of pretty, but empty buildings, but no members.
March 13, 2010
“I don’t admire DioSC or +Lawrence.”
Neither do I, TUaD. His enemies are wolves; he’s a dog who purports to “ordain” women. Canines both; let them both go to the devil.
Leave a comment
Support The MCJ
- Email the editor
- ©2010 Christopher Johnson
Archive
- September 2010
- August 2010
- July 2010
- June 2010
- May 2010
- April 2010
- March 2010
- February 2010
- January 2010
- December 2009
- November 2009
- October 2009
- September 2009
- August 2009
- July 2009
- June 2009
- May 2009
- April 2009
- March 2009
- February 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008
- October 2008
- September 2008
Search
Links
- 24thstate.com
- Ace of Spades HQ
- Across the Atlantic
- Across the Pale Parabola
- Adam Smith Institute
- American Prowler
- AmericanConservatives.net
- Amygdala
- Anchoress
- And Also With You
- Andrea Harris
- Anglican Church in North America
- Anglican Church of the Resurrection
- Anglican Curmudgeon
- Anglican Essentials Canada
- Anglican Friends of Israel
- Anglican Gazette
- Anglican Musings
- Anglican Network in Canada
- Anglican Planet
- Anglican Yinzer
- Anglicat
- Annika’s Journal
- anthill
- Anti-Idiotarian Rottweiler
- Apostolicity
- Asymmetrical Information
- BabyBlueOnline
- Bad Vestments
- Balloon Juice
- Barchester
- Bene Diction
- Beth’s Blog
- Betsy’s Page
- Beyond the Rim
- Bible
- Bible Belt Blogger
- Big Government
- Big Hollywood
- Big Journalism
- Big Peace
- Billy Ockham
- Bjorn Staerk
- Blaze
- Blazing Cat Fur
- Blithering Idiot
- Blogcritics.org
- Blogs of War
- Bovina Bloviator
- Brandywine Books
- Brothers Judd
- Brown-eyed Girl
- Buck Stops Here
- Buscaraons
- Captain Yips
- Chicago Boyz
- Christianity & Middle Earth
- Christianity Today
- Churchmouse Campanologist
- Citizen Smash(Indepundit)
- Clark Mountain Musings
- Clueless Christian
- ColbyCosh.com
- Cold Fury
- Cold Spring Shops
- Common Sense & Wonder
- Conblogeration
- Conservathink
- Conservative Blog for Peace
- Conservative Observer
- Cotton Country Anglican
- Country Keepers
- Craig Schamp
- Cranmer
- Cut On The Bias
- Daily Caller
- Daily Pundit
- Damian Penny
- Damian Thompson
- Dana Loesch
- David Janes
- David Warren
- Dawn Eden
- Day by Day
- Dean’s World
- DEBKA
- Dictionary
- Dispatches
- Dixie Flatline
- Doctor Weevil
- Dodgeblogium
- Dog’s Life
- Drell’s Descants
- Dunker Journal
- Dust in the Light
- Dyspeptic Mutterings
- E-Pression
- Eclectic Amateur
- Enter Stage Right
- episcoblog
- Episcopal Majority
- Est Quod Est
- eTalkinghead
- Eve Kayden
- Eve Tushnet
- FAIL Blog
- Fat Guy
- Fireworks
- five feet of fury
- Flit
- Free Canuckistan!
- funmurphys.com
- Gateway Pundit
- George Conger
- GetReligion
- GOCinAtlanta
- Greatest Jeneration
- Hey…Listen!
- Highway Video
- Hills of the North
- Hog Haven
- Holy Trinity
- Hoosier Review
- Horsefeathers
- Hot Rod Anglican
- HourEleven.com
- Hoystory
- Hugh Hewitt
- I Am Always Right
- Ibidem
- ICEJ
- Iconoclast.ca
- illinigirl
- IMAO
- In A Mirror, Dimly
- In the Agora
- Innocent as doves
- InstaPundit
- Interested-Participant
- Iowahawk
- Ipse Dixit
- Irish Elk
- Israpundit
- It Comes In Pints?
- It Don’t Make Sense
- Izzy Lyman
- JammieWearingFool
- Jay Reding
- Jeff Jarvis
- Jewish Voice and Opinion
- Jewish World Review
- Jim Treacher
- Joanne Jacobs
- John One Five
- Joyful Christian
- Junk Yard Blog
- Just Genesis
- Kathy Kinsley
- Kesher Talk
- Kevin Holtsberry
- Kraalspace
- Kyle Still Free Press
- La Shawn Barber
- Lead and Gold
- Let’s Try Freedom
- Lex Communis
- LilacRose
- lileks.com
- Living Church
- Machinery of Night
- Mark Byron
- Mark Shea
- Mark Steyn
- Mars Hill Review
- Martin Roth
- Marturia
- Massachusetts News
- Matt Welch
- MCJ Backup Site
- MCJ RSS feed
- MCJ Twitter
- MEMRI
- Meryl Yourish
- Mickey Kaus
- Milt’s File
- Moira Breen
- Morse’s Code
- mtpolitics.net
- Natalie Solent
- Neil Sheeran
- NewsCourt.com
- No Watermelons Allowed
- NorBlog
- Northern Plains Anglicans
- Not Weighing Our Merits
- Occasional Christian
- Off the Record
- Ole Miss Conservative
- One Hand Clapping
- Open-Air Mission
- opensecrets.org
- Orthodixie
- Other McCain
- Overlawyered.com
- Overtaken by Events
- Oxblog
- Paragraph Farmer
- Patio Pundit
- Patrick Ruffini
- Penitent Blogger
- Pennsylvanian in Exile
- Perpetua of Carthage
- Philosophical Blitzkrieg
- Piece of Work in Progress
- Pietist
- Pontifications
- Possumblog
- Post-Darwinist
- PrestoPundit.com
- Professor Bunyip
- Prolegomena
- Protein Wisdom
- Prydain
- Punch The Bag
- Pundit Tree
- Pyromaniacs
- Quantum Tea
- Quit That!
- Rafting the Tiber
- Rand Simberg
- Rantburg
- Rather Not Blog
- Red Stick Rant
- Redsugar Muse
- Reductio Ad Absurdum
- Reformed Pastor
- Regions of Mind
- Res Ipsa Loquitur
- Rest Across The River
- Right Left Whatever
- Right Wing News
- Romans 12:2
- Rumination
- samizdata.net
- SanctiFusion
- Sand in the Gears
- Scrappleface
- Sense of Events
- Sharp Elbows StL
- Shellfish
- Shelter in the Storm
- Shiny Happy Gulag
- Shot in the Dark
- Shots Across the Bow
- Silflay Hraka
- Sine Qua Non
- small dead animals
- Sneaking Suspicions
- Sofia Sideshow
- South Dakota Politics
- Southern Appeal
- spinline.net
- Spot On
- St. Louis Globe-Democrat
- Stand Firm
- Stephen Pollard
- Still on Patrol
- Stromata
- Telford Work
- Texanglican
- theosebes
- Thinking Meat
- Tim Blair
- TitusOneNine
- To all the world
- Tocquevillian
- Touchstone
- Touchstone Blog
- Transfigurations
- Travelling Shoes
- TribalPundit
- Trojan Horseshoes
- Truth about Israel
- Truth Laid Bear
- Two Braincells
- Tygrrrr Express
- Ugley Vicar
- Ugly Canadian
- undercurrent of hostility
- untold millions
- VCAC
- Veritas
- View from the Core
- View from the Right
- View Through The Windshield
- Viking Pundit
- VirtueOnline
- VodkaPundit
- Volokh Conspiracy
- wannabe anglican
- Weird Events
- worker in the vineyard
- Wunderkinder
- Wyclif.net


March 10, 2010